Thursday, 30 May 2013

Picking teams

"Yesterday I felt excluded. We were playing kick to kick footy at playtime and I'm not very good at marking. Sometimes I'd get it and kick it, or sometimes A would give it to me to kick. Then D told him not to give the ball to me cos I can't kick it high enough for them to mark. B said 'I don't want to be mean, but you just can't do it properly'.  They didnt want me to play. I left and found a teacher who got some other kids to play with me."

This is the story one of my boys was telling me this morning and it broke my heart.  And it brought back lots of memories. 

Memories of being asked to score, not play. Memories of making daisy chains in the outfield instead of trying to field because if the ball came to me, I would probably drop it and then be laughed at, so why try?  Memories of my friends picking teams for sport, and that look they would give me that said 'I'm sorry, I really do like you better than them, but I want to win, so I won't pick you' as I was left standing in the lineup till second last (there always seemed to be a kid worse at sport and that no one liked either, at least they liked me!). Memories of secretly loving the week in PE when we would do dancing - I could do that!  But the teachers and other students hated it and so I would enjoy it privately. Memories of school reports that were filled with As and glowing reports - except that one report on PhysEd that was not so great (though the teacher always wrote about how polite and well behaved I was). 

Stu has some similar memories, though not as many as I do. 

Our kids are clearly not genetically sporty. They not only lack the natural ability to run fast or have natural ball skills, but they are small - standing a good head shorter than most of their peers. They are not destined to be great football or cricket players. And mostly, we're all ok with that. 

The boys, like us, have loads of other abilities - they're brilliant at maths and English, they're creative too and they can do some physical activities really well (climbing trees and door frames for example).  But the lack of ability in sports can be a real confidence sucker. 

It seems that through our social (and school) systems, it is ok to be really competitive at sport, but not at intellectual activities. Schools have whole days of sports activities that are pure competition (sports day is our families' least favourite day of the year).  The situation my son found himself in yesterday is not nice, but it is scarily normal!  A similar scenario in the classroom would be much less likely to happen. 

As an adult, I've learnt that we are all different, and just because you can't play football, netball or tennis well doesn't mean you are not capable at something else. It makes me laugh that I was always one of the worst at PE, but now teach fitness/dance classes and dance for a living. Clearly, I am quite cabable physically, just not in what they wanted to teach me. 

I don't know how to deal with the issues my children are just beginning to have. Do I force them to go to footy/cricket/other sports clinics and practises so that they get better, even though they genuinely don't enjoy it snd have no natural ability?  Do we coach then ag home, even though none of us wants to spend our family time doung that?  Do I tell them to avoid playing those games at school?  My heart says to nurture what they are good at, and forget about the rest, but that won't make those school time issues go away. I don't know the answers. 

In the meantime, I tell the kids my stories and let them take solace in my history. I hope that they have the foresight to see that life is so much more than those school time dramas; that they'll find the thing that suits them and that they'll shine at one day. 

And for me, I'll hold dear the feeling I had on the weekend in a belly dance class, when I was picked first to dance with a group and I knew in my heart I was being picked for my skills - first time for everything! :)




7 comments:

  1. It's so hard!!! My 7 yr old loves sport(footy,soccer,and karate)but is not very skilled at it. He spends some lunchtimes in the library when 'they all play sport' & and says he's ok with it. What about when he's not ok with it? Hopefully someone has the answer??? Karen

    ReplyDelete
  2. If they want to play because they love the game, then it would be worth coaching them at home. If they want to play because that's what everyone else is doing, could you find something else they love, work on it at home till they're good, then they can start the new craze?. Just word them up so that they are able to include the other kids, not continue the 'lack of inclusion attitude'. Maybe yoyos or marbles if they're truly not sporty.

    Having said all that as though I'm some sort of authority, while buddy boy is included well in his school, he lives for boysy sports like footy and soccer. He's still learning the skills though so he's in the same boat. I wanted to cry when I watched them playing chasy the other day! No one chased him because he's no challenge. Life's tough and sadly kids will have bad times no matter what we do.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sorry for the long comment - that really struck a chord! Buddy Boy does lots of things well but the only area he excels is life skills like work around the yard. Raking, cooking, collecting wood - not much help at school!

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's a really emotive topic isn't it?

    Karen I remember kids that loved it but weren't that good at sport from school. The good news is that they both ended up with careers in sport, one of them a sports reporter for channel 10!

    Linda, one of the teachers at our school (actually the boys classroom teacher this year) is passionate about everyone getting a go. He admits to also being hopelessly unsporty, but pushes the kids to have a go and do their best. He has also introduced a program called Ground Force - it's a group of kids who spend time working in the gardens at school. They develop team skills and life skills. Some of the kids have behavioural problems and the physical work helps a lot. Others, like mine, need a confidence boost due to not being great in a standard area if school. I love the program for all of these reasons, and they take an environmental stance in things which is great too. Yesterday the boys helped remake some worm farms that had been relocated and they'll promote their use.

    Sorry for my really long response, but something like that would be great for Buddy Boy, I think.

    Oh, and I love the idea of introducing marbles etc. my kids love playing cards , perhaps that'd work (so long as they're not setting up a gambling ring at school LOL)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh goodness - I wanted to hug you (and your boy) when I read this (gushing warning) - this is a HUGE bug bear of mine...society pushing sports as a "profession" when it is really just a hobby - a GAME! My little girl is the same...she pig headedly wants to play footy with the boys but comes home in tears because she 'can't run'. I asked her if she wanted to keep playing footy and she did, she just wants to be able to do something like the others. Being so bright in academic skills is a problem in an educational institution...especially as they are so pigheadedly focussed on sport competitions (I actually made it clear to the school I felt they were wasting our time taking whole days dedicated to sports because that is not what I pay them to teach). Yes, I'm a frothing Mamma on this topic!! When I was in high school a bunch of us went to the principal about this exact problem and they introduced study hour. Basically a teacher would sit with the group of us who had no desire to play sport and do academic stuff (or brain sports), creative writing, reading, even arts...whatever we felt the desire to do and that fitted in with our subjects. We also had a term of self defence (the kind the police teach, not the karate kind) which was brilliant and I still remember all of it! It doesn't solve the lunch time problem and my girl often spends breaks in the library because of this...I've told her to find a cosy corner to read in if worst comes to it (they close the library at lunch) and if a teacher bothers her about it then she's to tell me :Z lol
    Another long, impassioned response there but it IS a horrid subject and such a common one (that schools have failed to address across many countries and many years) and whilst I'm all for kids learning life sucks I don't want them to think that sport matters - being fit, healthy and happy matters...which doesn't have to have a thing to do with sport....and I LOVE the sound of Ground Force...may suggest it at TFGs school.
    Okay, I'll stop frothing now :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. I got tears in my eyes when I read your post and these comments. Although I was/am naturally sporty and athletic and didn't face these issues at school BUT in primary school I was taller than most and weighed more and cringed when we did maths on body weight and height and charted ourselves in class. All I wanted was to be "little and cute" instead I was big and clumsy. As I got older others grew and boys in my class hit their growth spurts and overtook me but I retained my awkwardness and am still struggling to accept myself as I am.
    I think encouraging your boys to accept themselves as they are and giving them the support of having a group of people (family, friends) that love them exactly as they are is the key. They will continually find places/situations where they 'don't shine' and others do. Perhaps you could encourage them to accept this and be delighted that we aren't 'all the same' and how this means we can help each other and be interdependent, learn from and help each other to achieve things we can't do alone.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for the tips :) it helped me remember that my husband played chess as his sport at school, and his brother managed to get scrabble listed as an official school sport. Maybe your boys could do the same Tracy?? Karen

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for leaving me a message! I love hearing from you.